The Customer Loyalty/Customer Experience Conundrum


Share on LinkedIn

Marketers and marketing consultants all too often make the mistake of equating customer loyalty with the customer experience. Whether out of laziness or sloppiness, this is a critical miscue in the measurement, analysis and management of customer loyalty and experiences.

Loyalty is a relationship concept. While abstract, that concept is made tangible in the form of loyalty behaviors, the actions through which customer express their loyalty and which create value for a company. For any given customer, they express their loyalty to and generate value for a company by:

  • continuing to be a customer, which creates retention value;
  • buying more (or more expensive) products and services and giving the company a larger share of their spend, thus increasing cross-sell or upsell value; and
  • recommending the company to others, which drives referral or positive word-of-mouth value.

Companies want to connect with the rational and emotional dimensions of human decision making to cultivate a sense of loyalty as a means of increasing the likelihood that customers continue to display these behaviors, thereby maximizing the share of customer lifetime value captured by the firm.

Customers express their disloyalty by doing the converse of these things. Consequently, for any given customer, their lifetime value to a company is significantly greater if they behave loyally than if they behave disloyally. (Others, notably Fred Reichheld, have argued that loyal customers also pay a price premium and are less expensive to serve, but the case for a loyalty price premium/cost savings is far too muddled by counter examples to include them as a general assumption. Certain sectors also can realize a risk reduction value from loyal customers, but this generally is limited to those extending credit and insurance coverage.)

Every experience, every customer touch and interaction is an opportunity to deliver on the company’s value proposition and reinforce the relationship, and a risk of failing to deliver on customer expectations and weakening the glue of the relationship. Experiences matter because they affect and are part of the gestalt of the customer relationship. But the experience is not the same as the relationship, and loyalty is more than the sum of the customer’s experiences.

The customer experience can range from the fleetingly transactional, such as a stop at an ATM, to something far more planned, lengthy, complex and multi-sensorial, such as the periodic trip to the supermarket. The experience, however, is but a link in the relationship chain. Ever wary that the chain is only as strong as its weakest link, companies must attend to every aspect of the customer experience. But they also must recognize that, with few exceptions, they need to manage the experience as a means to the ends of solidifying the customer relationship.

Most companies – both B-2-B and consumer – need to focus on investing in customer experiences and processes that pay dividends by building and reinforcing customer relationships. Great customer experiences can become key differentiators from the competition, ways to attract customers and enhance customer loyalty. But firms must understand the difference between customer experience and loyalty before they can make the tactical and strategic decisions necessary to design customer experiences that have a positive payoff by building customer loyalty.

Republished with author's permission from original post.

Howard Lax, Ph.D.

Supporting better informed decision making with technology, research and strategy. With a focus on CX/VoC/NPS, Employee Engagement and emotion analytics, Howard's domain is the application of marketing information and SaaS platforms to solve business problems and activating CX programs to drive business objectives.


  1. Great article, Howard,
    We are personality marketers. By indentifying the prospect and customer personality types we can send them individualized, targetted messages that guide them along the Path to Purchase and are congruent with how they make their buying decisions. This better experience can lead to an enhanced, enduring, loyal relationship with increased advocacy for like-minded (same personality types) friends.

  2. This is very true. Often this is misunderstood and results are pretty vague in that situation. Customer Loyalty and customer experience are totally different. This mobile based loyalty programs are the newest hit in the market and every organization should cash in on this.


Please use comments to add value to the discussion. Maximum one link to an educational blog post or article. We will NOT PUBLISH brief comments like "good post," comments that mainly promote links, or comments with links to companies, products, or services.

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here