Is Link Building Dead?


Share on LinkedIn

Are We Hunters or Are We Farmers?

This past week had two major events of note. These included Google’s banning of MyBlogGuest and assessing a manual penalty on Portent, Inc. The penalty on Portent now appears to be lifted.

What are we to make of all this? Is Google seriously turning up the heat? This is something that I predicted in my 6 SEO Predictions Post for 2014 post for Search Engine Watch.

I think that we can safely say that Google is turning up the heat. actions bu Google are an outcome of more than a decade of hunter-like mentality by SEOs. What I mean by this is that many link builders played a see target: shoot target: kill target: eat target game. Vision involved nothing more than better, faster, and more efficient ways to kill more targets.

SEOs have been Hunters for links

The problem is that are now getting depleted of game. Google has invested enormous resources in protecting their franchise, and you can expect many more of these types of occcurrences throughout 2014 and on. Here are some of the lessons we need to learn:

1. Intent is Not What Matters: It is only the results that matter. Ann Smarty (the owner of MyBlogGuest) did not design her service to support spammy behavior, but it appears that much of that resulted, and this was exacerbated by the No NoFollow policy.

To Google, this ended up supporting bad link building practices by others. So regardless of Ann Smarty’s intent, Google did not like it, and they acted.

2. This Comes on the Heels of Matt Cutts January 20, 2014 Rant: If you have not read Matt Cutts post titled The decay and fall of guest blogging for SEO, go do so now. You can see the anger in it, and this is actually toned down from the way it read when he first published it. My perception is that the Webspam team is tired, frustrated, and yes, a little bit angry.

We need to view these two actions as significant shots across the bow, to serve notice that Google is going to be more proactive than ever in addressing link building practices of all kinds. To the best of their ability, they are going to force the conclusion they want, which is that link building with a hunter mentality is dead, and that links to your site should be a side effect of visibility and reputation building campaigns.

Link Builder Must Adopt a Farmer Mentality

3. Changes in Reconsideration Requests: For the first time recently here at Stone Temple Consulting we say a client get a message that Google was not going to take any more reconsideration requests from them for a few weeks.

The note basically was serving notice that this client was not doing enough to clean up links, and that they needed to cut much deeper than they had been. In addition, the note suggested that dealing with reconsideration requests was demanding on Google’s time (so please stop wasting it with premature requests).


It is time for SEOs to abandon their hunter mentality. Historically, most SEOs learned what things worked, and they went and did lots of that. There was no attempt to look at the big picture of marketing at all. In the case of guest posting, the goal was links from as as many different domains as possible.

If you think about it, this inevitably drives you to lower and lower quality sites and/or lower and lower relevance domains over time. This is not just about guest posting, but it is about link building as a practice. Time to get real. Let’s talk about some immediate actions you should take:

  1. STOP: putting rich anchor text links in any guest posts you do. Don’t argue with me. DO IT NOW.
  2. STOP: treating link building as a standalone practice. Get focused on marketing your business. As AJ Kohn says, “Links are the Result, Not the Goal”.
  3. STOP: focusing on the number of links. Quality is what matters most, by far. In fact, that volume approach is likely to directly hurt you!
  4. STOP: seeking links that no user is likely to ever click on.
  5. START: focusing on content marketing. More on this below.
  6. START: reviewing any past link building campaigns and get out in front of this. Clean it up before you get hit.

Content Marketing is the Way Forward

I say that with some trepidation as I know a bunch of people are going to rush out there, say they are doing content marketing and they are going to screw it up. Don’t treat content marketing as same s— different day. That is not going to work for you.

Content marketing needs to be about building your visibility and reputation online, and that’s the beginning and end of the story. If you do that well, you will inevitably do better in Google and Bing’s search results. Recall what Matt Cutts said in the interview I did with him in July of 2012.

By doing things that help build your own reputation, you are focusing on the right types of activity. Those are the signals we want to find and value the most anyway.

Successful content marketing programs will use a farmer mentality. Historically, farmers had to look at the big picture. They had to think ahead, plan for water shortages, rotate crops, find ways to store food for long periods of time, and more. Without the big picture, they did not prosper (credit goes to Sean Jackson for the hunter-farmer analogy).

What are the sites most likely to build your reputation the most? How can you partner with them to create awesome content that really engages relevant audiences? How much traffic can you get through those links you get? Is it going to be received well in social media? Will people engage with it? Will they be more pre-disposed to trust you and want to buy your product?

Link building is dead. The free money days of SEO are gone. If you made lots of money during those days, sit back for a second, celebrate your good fortune, sigh, and then focus forward on a new future.

This creates a fantastic opportunity for you. A lot of people are not going to get this transition right. You can. You can do it now. Embrace it. Make it yours. Rock on.

Republished with author's permission from original post.

Eric Enge
Eric Enge is a partner at Stone Temple Consulting (STC), which has been providing SEO Consulting services for over 5 years. STC has worked with a wide range of clients, ranging from small silicon valley start-ups, to Fortune 25 companies. Eric is also co-author of The Art of SEO book.


Please use comments to add value to the discussion. Maximum one link to an educational blog post or article. We will NOT PUBLISH brief comments like "good post," comments that mainly promote links, or comments with links to companies, products, or services.

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here