What the heck IS loyalty, anyway?


Share on LinkedIn

Is it your Net Promoter Score (NPS)? Customers who say they’re likely to purchase again? Some other survey metric?

Or is it something else.

If you spend as much time reading customer experience (CX) reports as I do, you might pick up on a theme. Many of us actually believe that if a customer says they’ll purchase more from us, then they actually will. So we call that loyalty.

I’m writing this on a flight to Anchorage, so I have plenty of time to catch up on my reading, including two reports from big-name firms that you definitely know. Each of these firms is trying to prove the effectiveness of their proprietary measurements by showing how they predict loyalty. And that’s critical – effective measurements should predict who purchases more. But proving that link it takes a lot of work.

I’ve worked with brands where Net Promoter Score is the best predictor of future sales. And others where it has no relationship. I’ve seen likelihood to repurchase tie to future sales, and seen no link. So I’m definitely interested in measurements that tie to loyalty – especially if they can do that across industries.

But the devil’s in the details.

Let’s look at one example of a big firm that purports to show how their measurement links to loyalty. When you review the details, it turns out that they define “loyalty” by the answer to three survey questions:

* Willingness to consider the company for another purchase
* Likelihood to switch business to a competitor
* Likelihood to recommend to a friend or colleague

This raises two primary questions:

First, if these are the true definition of loyalty, why would I EVER want to use three different questions to predict it? Especially if I have to pay this company a bunch of money to measure it. Wouldn’t I just ask these three questions and be done with it?

Sure, I need to ask driver questions about the relationship, website, product and other questions to determine why people are or are not loyal. But why would I want to use this vendor’s index of questions, when they themselves say that these other three questions equal loyalty?

But the second question is just as provocative: What the heck IS loyalty, anyway?

Here’s a radical perspective: Loyalty is a behavior, defined as when a customer purchases from us again in the future.

Okay, I said it. Loyalty is what we do, not what we say. That’s what I want to measure. And, more importantly, it’s also what your CFO wants you to measure.

Yes, it’s harder to measure behavior than it is to just ask three questions. You have to track which customers said what, and then track that back to their future buying. You have to wait long enough for them to repurchase or leave you.  You have to factor in refunds and purchase through distribution.  And that takes analysis.

But it’s the best way to prove that your CX program is truly effective.

And isn’t that what we’re really trying to discover, anyway?

Republished with author's permission from original post.

Jim Tincher
Jim sees the world in a special way: through the eyes of customers. This lifelong passion for CX, and a thirst for knowledge, led him to found his customer experience consulting firm, Heart of the Customer (HoC). HoC sets the bar for best practices and are emulated throughout the industry. He is the author of Do B2B Better and co-author of How Hard Is It to Be Your Customer?, and he also writes Heart of the Customer’s popular CX blog.


Please use comments to add value to the discussion. Maximum one link to an educational blog post or article. We will NOT PUBLISH brief comments like "good post," comments that mainly promote links, or comments with links to companies, products, or services.

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here