Barbeque buying experience: How Weber and Home Depot won my business


Share on LinkedIn

Having recently downsized into a condo and given away our large backyard barbeque grill, my wife and I were in the market for a new grill. Here’s how Weber and Home Depot won my business with the right product and experience.

Like most consumers these days, I started with a search on Google. Wow, “small barbeque grill” got over 4 million hits! Undaunted, I eventually checked out some of the major brands — like Char Broil and Weber — and retailers that I trusted — like, Home Depot, and Lowes.

In the process, I found several grills that could work, but it was hard to envision how they would fit on our small patio. So, I visited the local Home Depot to check out what they had in stock and see the dimensions.

Back online, I started narrowing down my options. Checking reviews was a key part of making a decision. It wasn’t as simple as which grill got the higher rating. Besides, I know that some reviews can be bogus. What really helped was the discussion of pros and cons. One Char Broil model I liked, but the reviews about a new “infrared” heating approach got mixed reviews. Even after seeing that specific grill in the store, I couldn’t quite figure out how this made grilling better, and decided to stick with a regular style.

Weber kept popping up, and this is where things got interesting. I never actually saw the Weber grill I wanted in person. But the photos and info on the retailer and manufacturer web sites, along with customer comments, sold me on the Weber Q 300. Doesn’t it look great!

Now, where to buy it?

The price was the same everywhere I checked. The main difference was shipping costs and/or pickup convenience. Lowes had a very expensive shipping option, Amazon and Home Depot were a bit lower. But I really didn’t want to pay (or wait) for shipping when there were stores nearby.

I decided to buy it online at and pick it up at a local store. The purchasing process was easy, almost as nice as I got the usual confirmation messages, along with a promise that I’d get an email and text alerts when the grill was available for pick up.

Unfortunately, I never got either alert. Checked online, found the grill was ready, and went to Home Depot to pick up. There the process was smooth — someone took my paperwork, got the grill from the back and helped me take it to my car.

Standing with this huge box at the back of my economy car, I realized it would never fit. So right there the HD guy and I unpacked the grill so I could fit the components into my car. Then, after saying he really wasn’t supposed to, he took away the packing material with a smile, saving me a lot of hassle disposing of it when I got home.

After getting it home, the grill was easy to put together. Nice clear instructions, wonderful design and only a couple of expletives when I banged a finger.

The story is not quite done yet, because we haven’t tried the grill yet. But I think there are some good lessons to be learned from this buying experience:

  • The product was most important. I picked the Weber grill because it had a unique combination of size and style that appeals to me. In other words, they totally nailed the “job to be done” for me.
  • Brand does matter. Whether it’s entirely fair or not, I was drawn to major brands that I had used or was familiar with. It’s possible I missed a better grill in the process.
  • Reviews influenced my decision. I didn’t ask any personal friends, but the online reviews were instrumental in making my decision from a short list of possibilities.
  • The purchasing location was a more subtle consideration. I like and wouldn’t give it a second thought for books and electronics. But for this purchase it just seemed to make more sense to buy from a home retailer.
  • Home Depot integrated clicks, bricks and people. While it wasn’t flawless, the retailer did a great job overall supporting my buying process online, in the store and with their staff.
  • A little something extra made it memorable. The final “touchpoint” where I got some extra help with the box in the parking lot was the cherry on top.

These days there’s a lot of talk about customer experience and a fair amount of hyperbole that it’s the only thing that matters, because everything is a commodity. Well, if I’m buying paper towels that may be true. But in this case the product was far and away the most important factor. Weber earned my business with its innovative design.

That said, when a product is available through multiple channels, the retailer that provides the best experience will get the order. In this case, Home Depot’s integration of online and offline shopping was most important to me.


  1. Hi Bob– I enjoyed reading about your grill-buying escapades as an example of a great customer experience.

    I particularly find it interesting how online reviews are affecting customer experience. You’re an expert, so you’re in tune with how online reviews affected your purchasing decision. I find it particularly interesting how reviews and social media affect the lay-person who isn’t even paying particular attention to it.

    For instance, on Amazon, the customer reviews are right there, directly under the product explanation. They are hard to ignore. My guess is that 80% of Amazon purchasers scroll down and read a few reviews without even thinking about it…

    Or, on a less apparent level, consider Spotify’s integration with Facebook. I see what my friends are listening to, which affects by listening decisions, which affects my buying decisions.

    From reviews to social media exposure, there is no denying that the internet and social media is influencing our buying decisions and our experience.

  2. Amazon is normally amazing, but situations like yours are the ones where retailers with physical stores triumphs online shopping platforms like Amazon. Glad you were satisfied with Home Depot’s purchasing process. In the future, when you buy large appliances from Home Depot, you should check My Move’s deals section to see if you can save more money. The website has tons of deals available for almost every retailer.


Please use comments to add value to the discussion. Maximum one link to an educational blog post or article. We will NOT PUBLISH brief comments like "good post," comments that mainly promote links, or comments with links to companies, products, or services.

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here