8 Essentials for Effective Online Communities


Share on LinkedIn

Article by Ernan Roman
Featured on DMA LATELY

Are you leveraging the power of your Community? How many of the following 8 requirements for achieving effective Communities are you using?

Communities have emerged as exceptionally high value and high ROI strategies for BtoB and BtoC marketers. They are the epitome of deep customer engagement and the power of peer-to-peer influence.

The following 8 requirements are based on thousands of hours of VoC research conducted by our firm for clients including IBM, MassMutual, Gilt, QVC, HP, Microsoft and Norton AntiVirus.

Per the research, please keep in mind that the following requirements are equally important for BtoB executives and BtoC decision makers.

Consider the implications on your business of the following VoC research-based definitions of Community;

  • A Community is a group of people united through a common interest to share information and exchange conversation.
  • Communities are exceptional ways for marketers to demonstrate a brand’s consumer commitment and interest.
  • A community needs to be a place of collaboration, not a place of advertising.
  • It needs to be a platform based on value that is derived from relevance and appreciation of time spent by members.

1. Tangible Value

When it comes to value, both BtoB and BtoC consumers stated that communities must offer tangible value to make it worth visiting or contributing.

BtoB decision makers expect communities to provide information that enables them to:

  • Stay up to date on issues that affect their jobs/roles and peers.
  • Learn about new solutions.
  • Collaborate and offer opinions.
  • Grow their professional network.

VoC Research Quotes

“I’m looking to see what’s going on amongst my peers to see if somebody’s fighting with the same technology pieces and parts that we are and if there’s any solutions out there.”

“I want a community that tells me as an IT professional where I can meet and talk to other IT professionals, look at career opportunities, and keep up to speed on new trends.”

BtoC value is driven by the ability to make better decisions:

  • BtoC buyers want to learn about products from experts and aspirational influencers (i.e., Oprah) but rely on peer networks and online reviews for feedback on the practical application/usage and efficacy of the product.
  • BtoC decision-makers stated that communities enable them to make “more informed decisions.”

VoC Research Quotes

“I feel like I’ve grown up with them and they’ve helped me mature my shopping habits. I feel like I’m buying higher quality and making better choices.”

“I enjoy shopping there because I can learn about other things I might be interested in from the other shoppers. We’re all moms trying to get by. It’s nice being part of a group where everyone is facing the same challenges and dealing with the same things.”

As a result, communities that revolve around reviews are especially valuable. Industry research has identified that:

  • 92% of consumers read online reviews
  • 40% of consumers form an opinion by reading just 1-3 reviews
  • Only 13% of consumers consider using a business that has a 1 or 2 star rating.

2. Safe Space

For both BtoB and BtoC, it was surprising how often the following was cited; the need for community participants to feel they can express themselves because they are in a “safe and supportive environment”.

Here’s a representative research comment from a CIO:

VoC Research Quotes

“CIO’S like me can feel embarrassed and afraid to ask or comment because we don’t know as much as we think we should, give our title. People have to feel they won’t be embarrassed or ridiculed if they ask a question or share an opinion.”

Some consumers articulated it this way:

“Sometimes people can be harsh and cruel. I don’t want to take that chance.”

Research participants stated that one of the primary ways to ensure a feeling of safety for community members was to have community managers who monitor conversations to prevent “out of line” comments.

3. Background and Credentials of Contributors

Both BtoB and BtoC buyers agreed that additional trust and credibility was given to reviews that had associated profiles to determine the reviewer’s “credentials and credibility”. The assurance that the poster was knowledgeable and “trustworthy” made the review even more valuable.

BtoB VoC Research Quotes

“My first thought, is it remotely possible this person has a clue about this issue?”

“I need to see how is writing the review. It makes a difference as to how much weight I assign it.”

“Need to know whether to trust the contributor. Need to see their profile. And, when I click on their profile, I expect their bio to come up, no matter how abbreviated it is.”

BtoC VoC Research Quotes

“I usually look up to see how old the person is who wrote the review about this category. People in their 40s and 50s are the most informed. Younger people don’t really know much about these things.”

“I need to see how is writing the review. It makes a difference as to how much weight I assign it. For instance, Mid-Westerners seem to like very different styles than us New Yorkers.”

4. Provide Compelling Reason to Contribute

For BtoB and BtoC, the quality of value provided by the community will motivate some to pay it forward by contributing input when they have something useful to share.

VoC Research Quotes

“The greater the value I have received from reviews, the more obligated I feel to reciprocate and submit a post to help others.”

“I don’t just want to be a taker. I want to pay it forward by taking the time to contribute my reviews to the community.”

5. Contributors Want to Feel Valued

The factor that separates a successful community from an overlooked community is the ongoing commitment to interact with, and acknowledge, those who take the time to actively participate in posting. These are the people who give the blog “life” and value.

Here are some representative BtoB and BtoC insights:

VoC Research Quotes

“I want to feel valued. Tell me how I am doing. How many people are reading my posts and evaluations? Is it helpful to them?”

“If I am investing my time to help other customers, I would like the company to give me some recognition. And it’s not just about discouts, recognition counts way more.”


Online community powerhouse, reddit has over 200 million unique monthly visitors in over 10,000 active communities. Erik Martin, reddit’s General Manager and original Community Manager, had this advice when thinking about community members;

“You’re not as smart as your users collectively. Just listen more and trust that the people who are passionate about the subject matter are going to do interesting and unexpected and amazing things with control you give them…. If you have customers who really want to talk about a certain subject, want do something with your product or show off something they’ve done with your product, you’re a fool not to embrace that.”

6. Company Hosting the Community Cannot Blatantly Sell

Brands need to understand that communities are a place to disseminate information — not marketing materials. A community must be a safe place for participants to seek and share stories, experiences, opinions and facts. It is an avenue for brands to demonstrate their commitment to helping consumers versus trying to sell them.

This comment from the research should be the gold standard by which brands build their communities:

VoC Research Quotes

“A good community gives a sense that you are dealing with peers versus something that’s being driven by the vendor to take you to products or marketing materials.”

7. Impact on Perception of the Hosting Company

Research findings were surprisingly consistent about the fact that people want to work with companies they perceive as “doing good things”, such as providing valuable information.

VoC Research Quotes

“Because of this community, [the company] is perceived to be a strategic partner not just a vendor.”

“It gives them a leg up [on the competition] in the sense that they’re not just trying to sell me; they are trying to help me learn from my peers that there are many ways to achieve our goals.”

8. Context is Critical

Overwhelmingly, the concept of relevance came up again and again in the VoC research. If the posts are not relevant and “relate-able” to the BtoB or BtoC audience, the information loses credibility and value.

VoC Research Quotes

“I need to evaluate the relevance of people’s posts. Need to know the writer’s title, size of their company, their reporting relationship and their industry.”

“Must know who the CIO reports to. There are differences between a CIO who reports to the CFO, or in some cases, God forbid, HR. Their challenges are distinctly different than the CIO who reports to the CFO.”

In Summary

To recap, following are the 8 requirements to help ensure that you deliver powerful community experience.

  • Tangible Value
  • Safe Space
  • Background and Credentials of Contributors
  • Provide Compelling Reason to Contribute
  • Contributors Want to Feel Valued
  • Company Hosting the Community Cannot Blatantly Sell
  • Impact on Perception of the Hosting Company
  • Context is Critical

Republished with author's permission from original post.

Ernan Roman
Ernan Roman (@ernanroman) is president of ERDM Corp. and author of Voice of the Customer Marketing. He was inducted into the DMA Marketing Hall of Fame due to the results his VoC research-based CX strategies achieve for clients such as IBM, Microsoft, QVC, Gilt and HP. ERDM conducts deep qualitative research to help companies understand how customers articulate their feelings and expectations for high value CX and personalization. Named one of the Top 40 Digital Luminaries and one of the 100 Most Influential People in Business Marketing.


Please use comments to add value to the discussion. Maximum one link to an educational blog post or article. We will NOT PUBLISH brief comments like "good post," comments that mainly promote links, or comments with links to companies, products, or services.

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here