3 Pitfalls of Redesigning Your Business Website


Share on LinkedIn

No business wants a website that looks dated – even if the content on the website is popular, interesting and engaging, visitors in all industries expect a certain experience when they visit a website. Failing to deliver a good user experience could lose your business customers. So it’s not surprising that companies want the best-designed website possible to attract and retain potential customers. The problem is that what some web developers and web designers understand by an effective website isn’t always a website that can be easily found online. And if people can’t find your website online then it doesn’t matter how good it looks or how useful your content is or how stunning your products – it simply won’t attract enough visitors.

I’ve nothing against web designers and developers (I used to be a developer myself for several years) but I am a firm believer that no website should be redesigned without the input of the digital marketing team because an effective website is most certainly not all about aesthetics and good branding, although they are, of course, an important part of the mix.

I’ve recently been involved with 2 businesses that have had their websites redesigned and fallen foul of several issues, some obvious and some less so. But for both, the outcome was a drastic fall in their search rankings and consequent loss of visitors to their websites and ultimately a loss of business. The image below shows a real-life fall of 35% in visitor numbers over a 2-month period due to a website redesign. So I’d like to share 3 potential pitfalls…

drop in organic traffic
Data Source

Changing The URL Structure

The URL structure is not just about good navigation around the website, it is also an indicator to Google and other search engines as to which pages are the most important. As an example, consider a consultancy firm that specialises in management consultancy but also provides financial and business consultancy services. They might have a structure with these 3 URL examples:


The first of these URLs (using the above structure) would be considered most important across the whole website and likely to appear higher in the search rankings. If, however, during a redesign the web designer decides it would make more sense to standardise the URL structure then it might be changed to:


But the financial and business consultancy pages will now be considered just as important as the management consultancy page and that could have a negative impact on the rankings of that page. In the worst-case situations, it can also lead to cannibalisation.

Removing Valuable Content

In order to make web designs clear and uncluttered web designers may recommend removing sections of content or even whole pages. Whilst removing pages with little content of any value is a good idea, it is never a good idea to remove valuable content from a page. Where there is a significant amount of content on a page (anything from 1,000 words upwards) then that content is contributing towards the search rankings and top-ranking pages will often have several thousands of words of content on them.

There are a number of ways to use design features to retain the content but also provide an uncluttered design. The most common of these is to use tabs or accordions, which enable search engines and human visitors to see the content when they want to.

Ignoring Page Speed/Experience

Since the summer of 2021 page experience has become a significant ranking factor, especially in relation to the Core Web Vitals metrics. These 3 standard metrics determine how quickly a visitor can see and interact with any page on a website and are impacted by the way a website is built. If, for instance, a website is redesigned in WordPress with multiple plugins it is likely to struggle to meet the minimum standards for Core Web Vitals. Similarly if a website uses overly large images the same is likely to be true.

These potential pitfalls are far from the only things that can go wrong during a website redesign but highlight the importance of involving someone with technical digital marketing experience in every website redesign.

Anna Preston
Anna Preston is a business management consultant and small business coach at Problogineer. She advises SMEs at all stages from start-up through to established companies looking to accelerate growth with tailored coaching to develop better processes, target growth and improve customer experience. She has a Bachelor of Science (BSc) in International Business Management from the University of Bristol, UK.


Please use comments to add value to the discussion. Maximum one link to an educational blog post or article. We will NOT PUBLISH brief comments like "good post," comments that mainly promote links, or comments with links to companies, products, or services.

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here