Outsourcing Inspiration: How Customer Feedback Creates Meaning at Work

2
927 views

Share on LinkedIn

Ever since James Heskitt’s seminal work published in the Harvard Business Review in 1994 entitled Putting the Service-Profit-Chain to Work, people have widely accepted the linear relationship that exists between satisfied employees, loyal customers and business results. The theory goes: happy employees make happy customers which make happy shareholders.

A wealth of data has been published since the early 1990s by PeopleMetrics and others that lend support to this formula. The terminology may be different but essentially the prevailing view is that employees who are engaged—emotionally connected to the work they do—are more likely to exert extra effort on behalf of customers which in turn creates an emotional connection between customers and the brand.


Figure 1



Emotions drive profits. Customers who ‘love’ a brand are more likely to return, tell others about it and even go out of their way to do business with that organization. But, new research indicates that this simple, direct relationship may be more complicated than originally imagined.

Customer-Centricity Leads to Engaged Employees

The soon to be released PeopleMetrics 2011 Employee Engagement trends report uncovers compelling evidence to suggest that organizations that adopt best practices in customer-centricity have more engaged employees. The study gathered feedback from more than 2,500 employees across a range of industries including: professional services, financial services, telecommunications, media and entertainment, retail, hospitality and healthcare we asked them to tell us about the customer-focus practices adopted by their companies.

Customer-centric organizations were defined as those where employees said:

a) Customers are:

  • Part of the Mission
  • Highly loyal
  • Invited to give feedback

b) And employees are:

  • Empowered to handle customer issues
  • Invited to give ideas on the customer experience
  • Provided customer feedback
  • Told when they have done a good job serving customers

Company-centric companies were defined as those where employees said that their companies did not apply these practices with the same degree of consistency. The analysis then examined how employees in these two groups (those working for Company-Centric versus Customer-Centric companies) rated their work experience and, in particular, how engaged they were with their employers.

The differences between the two groups are dramatic.

  • Two-thirds of employees in Customer-Centric companies are Engaged; and one in four are Fully Engaged (see Figure 2)
  • Contrast this with just 22% of employees in Company Centric companies who are considered engaged; and just 4% who are Fully Engaged




Figure 2

Furthermore, two to two and a half times as many employees in customer-centric organizations compared to company centric companies say that (see Figure 3):

  1. It would take a lot to get them to leave their current employer
  2. They are motivated by the work environment to give extra effort and
  3. They recommend their company as a great place to work
  4. They love their company or organization


Figure 3

Sharing the Customer Experience Creates Purpose and Meaning

One of the above practices is particularly impactful when it comes to the employee experience. Specifically, sharing customer feedback with employees cultivates a sense of purpose at work that is not there for those who do not receive that feedback.

  • Across industries, employees who are told when they have done a good job serving customers are 1.5 times as likely to agree “I get a sense of purpose from my work” (80% vs. 54% agree to feeling purpose, respectively)
  • Accordingly, the boost to a sense of purpose at work drives overall Employee Engagement upwards. Employees who receive customer Recognition are 4.5 times as likely to be Engaged compared to those who do not receive this feedback (55% Engaged vs. just 12%, respectively)

Bringing the Customer inside the Company

In a recent HBR article How Customers Can Rally Your Troops, Adam M. Grant, management professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School, provides in depth insight into this idea. He references companies who “outsource inspiration” by bringing in customers and end users to tell their stories to front line employees. The results of these endeavors provide evidence that while traditionally leaders and managers have felt the responsibility to “rally the troops” toward better performance it is actually meaningful customer feedback that holds the greatest influence on employee motivation.

So perhaps we need to reconsider the service profit chain, perhaps it looks something more like the image in Figure 4—a service profit loop.




Figure 4

Companies need to start by admitting that employees need to find meaning and purpose in their work beyond a paycheck. And those companies that start to actively look for ways to outsource inspiration will be rewarded by higher levels of Employee Engagement and better business results.

2 COMMENTS

  1. Kate… Figure 4 in particular is powerful for me. I think it is critically important that companies identify how to positively influence Employee Engagement.

    Unfortunately, a lot of blog posts in sweep this a bit under the rug by glossing over Employee Engagement with the mindset of “just make your employees happy.”

    From my experience, Employee Engagement is a direct reflection of two important factors.

    1. Job Fit. What is the Job Fit of each employee team member? Low Job Fit employee team members must be held accountable to how they treat the Customer and their key accountabilities on a day-to-day basis.

    2. Management. What is the management approach and Job Fit of the manager? Does the manager understand how to really connect with each employee team member? Do they know how to build rapport, lead, set the vision, and hold people accountable?

    Happy employee team members do what they believe in. They are “wired” for the job. Happy employees team members do what they want to, not what they have to. Unhappy employees destroy Customer Value and reduce the morale of the team by not doing their job well and not taking care of the Customer the way they should.

    Rock on!

  2. Thanks for the feedback, Chris. You are spot on in your observations.

    I’d add a 3rd dimension on top of job fit and management which is Leadership. Engaged employees need to understand leadership’s vision, trust in leaders’ abilities to make the right decisions, and see that their own feedback is solicited, heard and, in the right circumstances, acted upon.

    Thanks again for the comment.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here